| | 1665 | Thomas BROWNRIGG buried 20 Jan 1665 @ Matterdale |
| 1675 | 1718 | Thomas GRISEDALE married Elizabeth Grisedale @ Greystoke 2 Nov 1675; buried 1 sep 1718 @ Matterdale |
| 1719 | 1721 | Joseph CLARKE licensed 6 Jul 1719 |
| 1721 | 1724 | William TAYLOR licenced 17 Mar 1721. Buried 11 Dec 1724 @ Matterdale. |
| 1725 | 1731 | Thomas WALKER licensed 11 May 1725. Moved to Kirkby Thore 1731. Buried 23 Jan 1746 @ Kirkby Thore. |
| 1731 | 1737 | John ATKINSON buried 28 Oct 1737 @ Matterdale. Wife, Catherine buried 16 Jan 1753 @ Matterdale. |
| 1739 | 1743 | Joseph WOOF licensed 24 Dec 1739 resigned before 1743. |
| 1743 | 1790 | William WRIGHT licensed 6 May 1743. Buried 7 Dec 1790 [aged 90] @ Matterdale. Wife, Barbara buried 22 Jul 1789 [aged 92] @ Matterdale. |
| 1791 | 1827 | Jonathan HARRIS licensed 12 Feb 1791. Buried 17 Nov 1827 [aged 73] @ Matterdale. |
| 1828 | 1832 | John KIRKBY [vicar of Mayfield, Sussex 1810] licensed 28 Mar 1828 @ Matterdale. Buried 23 Nov 1832 [aged 75] @ Matterdale |
| 1833 | 1842 | Joseph THOMPSON licensed 22 Sep 1833. Buried 15 Apr 1842 [aged 53] @ Matterdale. |
| 1842 | 1846 | John Woodham DUNN licensed 2 Dec 1842. Vicar of Dalston 1846 - 53. Vicar of Warkworth 1853 - 83. Buried @ Warkworth [M.I. "born September 17th 1812 died September 18th 1883"] |
| 1846 | 1851 | William Robert DUNCAN born 22 May 1820, licensed 16 Sep 1846. Senior curate @ St Peter's, Liverpool 1854 - 98. Died 12 Feb 1898. |
| 1851 | 1894 | John BELL licensed 7 May 1851; died 4 Jan 1905 & buried @ Penrith Cemetery. Wife, Margaret, buried 1 Jun 1872 @ Matterdale |
| 1894 | 1905 | Robert Vipond NANSON previously of Rochester, Kent; Finchingfield, Essex; Havering-atte-Bower; Aldham, Essex; Little Easton, Essex; Little Bentley, Essex; Manningtree, Essex. Resigned in 1905 to reside @ Woodcroft, Penrith. |
| 1906 | 1926 | Henry Eldred WOOD previously of Stanwix, Cumberland; Haughton-le-Skerne; Gilsland with Over Denton. |
| 1926 | 1936 | William Edward HEARN |
| 1936 | 1943 | Richard STOTT |
| 1946 | 1950 | Fergus Donald SHORT |
| 1950 | 1956 | James Arthur BELL |
| 1956 | 1959 | Eric BRAITHWAITE |
| 1959 | 1965 | Bishop E GRAHAM |
| 1965 | 1974 | David J FOSTER |
| 1975 | | Godfrey MARSHALL |
| 1976 | 1981 | David WEBSTER |
| 1981 | 1987 | David C CROOK |
| 1987 | 1990 | Robert J IRETON |
| 1991 | | Raymond WALKER |
